Showing posts with label youth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label youth. Show all posts

Thursday, 15 November 2012

Do we have the politicians we deserve?


In 1811, Joseph de Maistre, a philosopher, writer, lawyer, and diplomat stated:
Joseph de Maistre. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Every nation gets the government it deserves


Was he right or not? The fact is that no-one can know for sure. Nevertheless, his aphorism has some elements of truth. For example, in Greece corrupt government officials were succeeded by corrupt government officials, with the public knowing everything about what was going on. Yet, nothing was done (and yet still almost nothing is being done) about it. The same situation holds in Italy where politicians were found celebrating themselves and their families in Caribbean cruises and yet, except from the momentary public anger and disdain nothing else occurred. The same politicians and policymakers returned to their office after the end of their luxurious journeys and assumed work like everything was right in the world.

Obviously, one cannot state that corruption does not exist in the other Member-States of the EU, or other parts of the world. Corruption has always existed and will always exist. The problem is that we cannot tolerate it. People who steal money from the government, who are tax evaders or who take bribes to perform their work correctly should be sentenced to jail and have their properties confiscated. Instead, in many countries these persons and tactics are considered the norm and those who wish to live in that country need to respect these norms themselves.

Who or what is to be blamed then for this situation? The answer is simple: nothing else than mentality should be pinpointed for this. The mentality, mostly presented in older persons who in their turn try to pass it on to their children, that if you want to succeed in the system you have to accept it. A friend once stated that if you wanted to change them system then you had to become a part of it first. However, becoming a part of it means that you have to change your ideas and notions about it if you are to succeed in it. Thus you risk becoming just the person you swore you wouldn't become.

How can change be achieved then? Protesilaos Stavrou in one of his latest articles states that change can only come form the Greeks and not from the Troika. The same holds for the Italians, the Spanish, the Cypriots and the Portuguese. Change only comes from within. And as many of the older generation feel the anxiety that the status quo it had guarded for years is about to collapse, many of the younger generation feel confident that all those which had been tormenting them all these years are about to disappear.

Change is hard to endure, more so if you are used to something else through your lifetime. It has been documented in economics that the labour force changes its skills much rarely than every other factor of the economy. As a generalization the same holds in politics as well as ideologies.

The situation cannot change if we cannot change ourselves. If we demand more democracy, more transparency and less corruption then we are going to receive it. Change will not come in a day nor in a week. Yet, it will come soon if we all decide we are fed up with the situation.

Friday, 26 October 2012

Youth, Politics and Incredibility

European Leaders on Vacation. Can you spot a young one? Picture Credit: Euronews
 Recently, the Cypriot Ministry of Finance had reevaluated its estimation on the country's fiscal deficit. The new estimation assumed that the 2012 fiscal deficit would amount to 4.5% of GDP, instead of the 3.5% it had originally announce. Now, as the negotiations with Troika are supposed to come to an agreement, new evidence show that in the January-September period of 2012, fiscal deficit amounted to about 3.27% of GDP, instead of 3.08% over the same period in 2011. Note: 2011's deficit reached an astonishing 6.3%.

Although I have credited incredibility as the main source of trouble for most of the EU-periphery, it looks like no-one has learned anything about what I have been saying for months. It is a political tradition in the South to promise things you cannot deliver. And people have always known about this, yet the times when they actually chose to do something about it were extremely rare. People, especially politicians, have very short memories. It looks like they cannot even remember what they promised, promoted, supported last week if this goes against their interests. The worst thing about this situation: People always followed and supported them.

It is really annoying to find people nowadays who are still blinded by ideology. And ideology based on what? A politicians ideas and slogan? I am not at all against believing in people. Far from it. But following people, and especially obsolete political parties, blindly is what got us to this situation. 

People (especially the young) do not believe (much less trust) their governments anymore. Why should they? What has changed over the last 10,20 or sometimes even 30 years? Just the faces. The same ideas, the same persistent ideologies, the same arguments we have heard for thousands of times over the course of our lifetime and that we have grown so accustomed to that we have even stopped paying attention to what they say. 

Why? Because all they do is talk. Assigning blame to one another, talking about what should be done, about what they should have not done, talk, talk, talk. As for action: none.

I do not know whether they have heard that actions speak louder than words. Well, they do really. Most of the people in the EU are now looking at their governments with mistrust. They know they supposedly are there to serve them but what do they do: they serve themselves. 

People in governments, especially those older than 50, are still reminiscing of a time where the world is not as it is now. When they could promise and not deliver, when incompetence did not matter, where people believed and admired politicians in spite of their inability to rule. Well, this is over. The world moves forward and it seems like they are getting left behind. 

It is not just them, however. It is their voters as well. People who are of a certain age, who are too old to protest, to do anything else but work. People who did not have the same access to information and world events, like we now do and who are too stubborn to change their mind, not because they have some good arguments for their beliefs, but because having those belief has so defined them that they can no longer change.

From what I hear, you have to be at least 25 years of age to be elected in the parliament, and over 35 to be elected as a Prime Minister/President. Yet, the majority of nation leaders are much older than that:
  • Mariano Rajoy - Spain: 57
  • Mario Monti - Italy: 69
  • Antonis Samaras - Greece: 61 
  • Demetris Christofias - Cyprus: 66
  • Pedro Passos Coelho - Portugal: 48
  • François Hollande - France: 58
  • Angela Merkel - Germany: 58 
In comparison, Sweden's Prime Minister was only 42 when he was elected, Denmark's was 45 as was Norway's. Even more impressive, Finland's Prime Minister, Jyrki Katainen, was just 40 years old when he was elected in 2011, having before been voted as the best Finance Minister in Europe by the Financial Times in 2005, when he was just 34.

I would not support that every young person is better than any older person. Yet, as you may see from above, the political scene in the South needs immediate youthification. And this are just the ages of the nations' leaders since I could not get my hands on the Parliament's average age or the average Cabinet age in each country . I am sure that we will find that most of them are near (if not) retired as well.

The problem is not so much age as persistence to a failed system and false (or belonging to a different age) ideologies. Youths usually lack experience yet they more than compensate for that with drive, determination and the belief that they can change the world. As the older generation sits back, protesting in their armchairs that the world would never change, the youth try to make the change. 

The young ones do not possess the pessimism surrounding most of the older generation. They start life with enthusiasm and will to achieve something to make the world a better place. Yet, due to this political mechanism under which politicians are elected only when they reach retirement age, pessimism and inaction are substituted with more pessimism and inaction. 

The situation reminds me of a George Bernard Shaw quote (although a bit modified to suit the situation):
 
The old look at the world and think "Why?" while the young look at it and think "Why not?".

Friday, 31 August 2012

3 Ways to Fight Unemployment in Europe

Although as stated yesterday, the light at the end of the tunnel is not so far, it is nevertheless a light concerning only macroeconomic variables for the time being. And as is well known, no man can eat on GDP only. (If anyone has proof of the opposite please inform me immediately!). The following graph is copied from a Eurostat press release dated July 31st:
As you may remember and confirm from the above graph both the EU27 and the EA17 unemployment rates have been rising over the past few months. The same holds for youth unemployment which reached 22.6% in the EU27 and 22.4% in the EA17, also rising over the last months. The situation appears to be even worse when one considers that many youths are not on the list because they have not applied for unemployment benefits or have not communicated with their state unemployment agency (recent graduates for example). Even if all macroeconomic indicators move to positive ground the biggest issue European countries (especially in the South) have to face is unemployment. There are however three ways (or policies) which can assist in creating more jobs.

(i) Promote start-ups and spin-offs by youths
The reason I believe that start-ups are important is because they provide the foundation for future growth in an economy. True, they usually need very few people when they begin, however, their growth may be spectacular. (Google, a Stanford University spin-off now employs more than 50,000 employees worldwide) Obviously not every start-up or spin-off can be Google. This is, however, irrelevant to the policy. Even if they end having about 10-20 employees it is more than great. Small and medium businesses (SME's) account for 99% (!) of all EU businesses. EU policies are stating to be in favor of SME's and yet little is being done in order to promote entrepreneurship. I have personal experience of EU funds being targeted to existing businesses in amounts of about 100,000 euros. The EU could have funded 3-4 business start-ups with these and I am not even allocating them correctly (usually, seed money for start-ups or spin-offs are in the realm of 15-20,000 euros). Universities should also be encouraged to spin-off their researchers' discoveries as this may create several successful businesses and employ many graduates (let alone the stream of money the university will gain from the spin-off). Not to be misunderstood, when I say youth, I include all people under 35 not just the under-25's the statisticians consider when they create their tables.

(ii) Promote research in Universities
 With the notable exception of the UK, most universities in Europe are funded by their home nations (maybe some benefactors as well). EU-wide, research-promoting policies would essentially mean that the Universities would have to hire graduates in order to assist to that research. A clause should force them to do so, in the rare case that some Universities will choose not to create a research position for their grant. The current is that many EU Universities earn EU grants, many of which however are targeted to the professor(s) applying. These policies should be expanded in order for job positions to be created, alongside with (i) so that Universities can themselves gain even more from this. An additional advantage for the potential researchers is that jobs of this kind usually pay a lot more than average salary.

(iii) Force distressed large firms (e.g. banking institutions) to spin-off operations
Consider the following scenario: a company which employs 100 people decides to cut its operations in half and create two separate companies. How many people do you think that the two companies will need in order to function properly? If you guessed 50 then you got it wrong. A new company will need new management, and a reallocation of job positions which will almost certainly create more jobs than if it continued to be a single one. The idea that one large company needs less people than two separate ones is called economies of scale in economics. However, I do not mean that companies should be forced to spin-off operational parts. This should only occur with insolvent (or sometimes solvent as well) banks or other companies which face bankruptcy: spinning-off a part would make them focus more on what they do best instead of having to allocate sources all over the place. Even if they end up collapsing, the damage will be less for the economy if less people lose their occupation and the companies are smaller after the spin-off.

The three propositions above are ranked by their ease of implementation. For example, I believe that (i) is the easiest to implement and is also the one which will prove to be the most lucrative for economies. Something that is targeted in that direction is the announcement of the Italian government that people under 35 will be able to start a company with as little as 1 euro for capital. However, the need for more targeted policies, especially at the EU level remains and is now more important than ever.

Sunday, 26 August 2012

Mario Monti and the Lost Generation

One piece of news which made a great impression on me was this: Italy's Secretary to the Prime Minister Antonio Catricalà has stated that youth under the age of 35 can start a business with only 1 euro as capital. I have said it before and I will say it again now: Mario Monti is amongst the best politicians (albeit an economist) who have ever set foot in the European stage. He cares about his country and is neither blinded by ideology nor afraid of any political consequences either at the national or the European level. He does what he knows best: revive the Italian economy.

It is the first sample of growth policies we have seen in the EU for months now. Announced measures for infrastructure in Italy are expected to reach 300 billion euros from now until 2020. Troubled areas in Rome, Naples and Florence are expected to receive an "upgrade" worth approximately 2.5 billion. 400 million are expected to be invested in internet technology to digitize the country's social services and boost buying and selling through the internet. For me what is most important is what I began with: every youth until the age of 35 may start a business with as little as 1 euro for capital.

It would be amazing if we could see such action from other member-nations of the EU. For the time being only Monti was able to show that he truly understands the situation and is willing to do something about it. What are we waiting for? For youths to start migrating from the EU to Australia like it is currently happening in Greece? (read this detailed article in the Guardian for more information). Should we stop and watch as people under 30 are constantly leaving their native nations for a "better" life elsewhere?

Mario Monti has spoken of a lost generation. What he meant were the myriads of young Italians fleeing the country in order to find employment elsewhere. Many leaders speak of the future, while they focus their policies to the over-50's population. The future cannot exist without the young. I remember Ernest Hemingway's story in the 1920's Paris: an old garage director told his young subordinate that he belonged to "une génération perdue". Hemingway wondered whether the youth who had seen the evils of war, were disciplined and polite could really be considered lost.

The same rationale holds today. Who is worse off might I ask: the person whose salary was reduced from 3000 to 2500 euros or the person who is desperately searching for a job and cannot find one? Yet with the notable exception of Italy, no nation (or politician for that matter) is doing anything about it.

Tuesday, 21 August 2012

Should the Crisis last?

Although I have yet to see any decisive action from politicians and policymakers in the EU I have the notion that from 2013 the situation will be better for the Union. I base this on the current actions by private banks, which are either selling their non-core loans or trading their existing loan portfolio in a country, in order to deleverage themselves (for details read this). I would assume that banks, tired of waiting for the officials to act, have decided to take action into their own hands. 

What worries me more than overcoming the crisis, is overcoming it without the opportunity to learn something from it. If the crisis terminates and we have the banks to thank, what would politicians and policymakers have done about it? Practically nothing. At the same time nothing will be done to safeguard the Union's future, as no extra authority will be given neither to the ECB nor the European Council. If the same causes provoke another crisis in the future nothing will be able to halt it at its beginning, since no measures have been taken now.

If the crisis ends without any political (or government) intervention then politicians will understand that they need to do almost nothing to correct the situation: procrastination, austerity measures and maybe a stimulus package will be more than enough. It would also mean that Southern Countries, with their productivity to the low end of the EU average will have done nothing to correct the situation. Cyprus, Portugal and Italy will continue to see their people work more than everyone else, alas, with lower productivity. You may notice that I exclude Greece from this. In my opinion Greece will be the nation which will mostly benefit from this situation. It is the only nation which has been through the process of reorganizing its finances, cutting excessive spending and making reforms and structural changes in its economy. Although the speed of this process is not one which would allow it to witness less contraction and unemployment, the process itself will be beneficial for the nation, something which will be more visible in the next 5 years. Nevertheless, had the process been slower the negative effects would have been less now, with the positive ones still occurring. (this scenario is of course based on the assumption that Greece will be given the extra €2.5 billion it will need this year, and will remain both within the Union and the Eurozone, which it should!)

On the other hand, Cyprus, Portugal and Italy have done little yet to correct this situation. Although all countries have undertaken measures to reduce their fiscal deficit (which is good if they are aimed at reducing irrational expenses), I have not yet seen one take any measures to increase productivity. What we so far witness is tax increases, salary cuts and reductions in pensions. All of which are mainly aimed at the older population!

As for the youth? It seems that no country has so far taken any action towards reducing youth unemployment or implementing incentives to increase start-up creation.  Have a look at youth unemployment in the EU (source: Eurostat)
Both the EU-17 and the EU-27 youth unemployment are over 22%! And nothing is yet to be done about this situation. I am guessing that until a change of mind occurs to the heads of politicians and policymakers, no change will occur in the EU. Well, I hope that the crisis lasts enough for them to make that change.

Monday, 6 August 2012

Start-ups, Democracy and Growth

While the economic climate is deteriorating rapidly in South Europe what seems to raise our expectations about the future is the fact that in Spain, with unemployment reaching 25% and youth unemployment more than 50%, young people have began creating start-up businesses as a response to the economic crisis in the country. (for more information concerning start-ups in Spain read this).

Europe, especially in the South, does not have the same mentality or maybe not even the same resources when it comes to start-ups and establishing new businesses, as countries like the US or Israel do. The only nation in the EU that comes near this mentality is the technology-oriented Estonia which in 2005 it became the first country to offer Internet voting nationally in local elections. The feature itself is very impressive and something I would love to see in all countries. This will bring a new era in democracy, allowing citizens to have a direct opinion on many aspects of national affairs through courses of action like referendums. For those who love numbers 1.9% of the Estonians (approximately 9,300 people) voted online in 2005 whilst the percentage rose to an impressive 15.4% (150,800 persons) in the 2011 parliamentary elections.

Returning on the start-up discussion, with a simple visit to the EU grants website the reader may observe how many grants are targeted in  start-ups. Exactly none. Entrepreneurship is left to be promoted by individual countries and not at the EU level. Nevertheless, whilst in the UK (and to a much lesser degree in Germany), entrepreneurship attracts a rather significant amount of young talent, the South European mentality states that a job at a large corporation or in the government sector is a much more prestigious one. This is rooted in genes of all South European people, maybe a fact which derives from the instability in governments over the last century and has resulted in a need for a stable job, salary and life. (remember that Italy, Spain, Portugal and Greece suffered through dictatorship regimes over the last century, with all of them experiencing terrorist attacks over time and Cyprus had been prone to rough civil disputes and a Turkish invasion in 1974). These experiences lead to a risk-averse society, with the specific mentality passing on to the next generations.

However, when talking to today's youth, this mentality seems to be changing. This might be the result of the economic catastrophe the aforementioned countries are facing, where the most stable of organizations of the past, the banking institutions, are proposing layoffs and shrinking of business activities to survive. It seems that the most prestigious employers have lost their reputations.

My hope for the future is that EU governments understand the importance of start-ups in the economy and provide financial assistance, in the form of subsidies or state-owned Venture Capital (VC) firms to aid individuals get the funding needed to start their business. This need only be done for a short period of time, since after the initial phase, more and more privately held VC firms and angel investors will emerge. The cost of funding a start-up is also very low as most of them require less than 100,000 euros to function. Given the amounts each country spends on foolish expenses each year sparing 10 million a year for start-up funding is infinitesimal. On the contrary, the outcome of such policies will be extremely beneficial as the now deteriorating economies will be able to bounce back, create thousands of jobs and restore confidence in the nation as a whole.