Showing posts with label population. Show all posts
Showing posts with label population. Show all posts

Monday, 4 November 2013

Pension Systems in Declining Populations

Pension Funds
The global asset management industry has been booming over the past decade. Only in 2012 assets under management were up by 9% reaching $87.2 trillion. Of that, approximately 40%, or $33.9 trillion, were held by pension funds. To get a grasp of the size these funds the graph on the right indicates their sizes relative to GDP. As one can easily observe, pension fund assets in the UK and the US exceed 110% of GDP while they account for approximately 50% of the world's GDP.
Figure 1
Although many countries (according to the OECD) are still mainly funded through public pay-as-you-go (PAYG) systems (Pillar I), a shift towards mandatory private pension funds (Pillar II) and voluntary ones (Pillar III) is observed. The increased popularity of privately-held pension funds can be attributed to a more "free-market" view of the world; the private sector can do it just as well as the public sector so why not let the former do all the job? The private sector has done its job excellently so far: pension funds usually focus on relatively conservative investment strategies (a comment from someone in the industry was "we are playing with people's retirement so we focus on low-risk products") and although their allocation has been increasingly focused on bonds and bills as the following graph shows, their returns have been relatively good for the 3-year average (see the OECD publication for details).
Figure 2
Although the fact that the private sector is doing its job very well may suffice as an excuse on the tremendous growth of  pension funds, reality offers additional justification: people are expected to live much longer than they did half a century ago thus they require more money to preserve a decent standard of living for longer (FlipChartRick has an excellent article on Pieria concerning the changes in distribution of the UK population since the 1900's). Additionally, the growing population of the elderly increases fears of PAYG systems facing trouble with funding. Compliment that with a slight need humans have to earn more and more (commonly known as greed) and the need for pension funds is increased.

Yet, what we have failed to observe is that focusing purely on the private sector to provide funding has its own issues. The PAYG system mainly took contributions from workers and passed them on to pensioners, investing the rest in government bonds. This basically means that nothing in the economy changes by much: what contributors lose, pensioners get and the remainder is returned to the people via government spending. Government spending can (and does) increase consumption, yet as David Ricardo noted "In point of economy there is no real difference in either of the modes, for 20 millions in one payment, 1 million per annum for ever, or £1,200,000 for forty-five years are precisely of the same value". In essence, although an increase in government spending can produce short-term increase in consumption, the government will eventually have to lower consumption to repay for the loan. (obviously this does not take into account multiplier effects which propagate the increased consumption shock and, with the assistance of the private sector make the shock last longer. Yet, if we strictly look at just government spending the above holds)

As Figure 2 shows, private pensions, just like PAYG, take contributions, pay out the pensioners and use the rest to invest. Yet, the investment strategy is much different: although both invest in bonds and bills, pension funds also invest in property, equity, derivatives and hold a significant amount in cash. Although funds hold about 20% of their assets in equities, the sheer number of that investment is astonishing if one remembers the total size of the market. As stated before a protracted period of increasing prices rises the money supply in the economy. In addition, as property is becoming more and more important given its "safety", more funds are allocated there, resulting in increased demand and higher prices. The following two graphs are indicative of the correlations of pension funds and housing:
Figure 3 Case-Shiller Housing Price Index
Figure 4
Although Figure 3 dates from the 1890's, the sharp drop in 2007-2008 can easily be seen, just like the one Figure 4. The drop would have been more visible in Figure 4 had I been able to find assets in dollars and not as a percentage of GDP. The reason is that US GDP also fell drastically during that period and thus although assets took a tumble the result is much less steeper than it should have been.

In general, it seems that private pension funds are actually contributing to inflation by increasing property, equity and bond prices (while reducing their yields). As the quest for safe assets becomes more and more intense, with pensioners increasing every year, the need to invest money in order to obtain a return which would make the fund sustainable makes bonds and property more valuable than ever before. This, as mentioned before, increases prices (and lowers bond yields) thus making money supply increase. 

As Charles Hugh Smith notes if yields are falling how will pension funds continue to exist, especially if the elderly population increases? The answer will most probably be through property and equity, which will create a short-term boost to their returns. Will this be permanent though?

Declining Population
Suppose that we have 100 units of currency in a population of 100 people, each person owning a unit. Suppose now that in a few year's time, the population is decreased to 80, now with each person owning 1.2 units if money is stable. Would that mean that consumption is decreased? The answer is that it depends. If people tend to spend more than before then consumption might not be reduced. Yet, even if consumption per capita increases it will occur at a diminishing rate. It has long been the case (Kuznets, 1955) that people spend less of their income as their income rises. In simple terms, even you are making a million a year you will probably not be buying a new TV every 2 months to compensate for the lack of demand. 

In this scenario, superabundance is rapidly reached: more than enough goods for every human being, yet with declining demand. Declining population will have many interesting side-effects: as already mentioned long-term rates are greatly affected by the rate of population growth. Yet, if population growth is zero or negative it will mean that these rates will also become negative or zero. My guess is that they will fluctuate on slightly positive ground if population is stable due to liquidity preferences and they will be less negative than the rate of change of the population if it is negative, for the same reason. Whether this is enough to compensate for the increased percentage of the elderly in total population and the increased need for safe assets which will make bond yields even more negative is to be seen.

Interestingly enough, in such a scenario inflation is not out of the picture. As the elderly consist of a growing part of the population and long-term bond yields tend to zero or negative, more investment in real estate and equity will occur, resulting in a rise of property and stock prices thus creating a boost in money supply. This will lead to an environment of short-term inflation due to money supply increases either through private actions like the ones described here or through public ones, i.e. printing. In such an environment banks will have a diminished role: less demand for lending will essentially mean less bank-created money.

If one thinks of a yield curve in this scenario then it would have to be an inverted, gradual-sloped one, at times resembling a fixed curve. Rates should be slightly positive in the short-run due to inflation persistence, while in the long run they should be more prone to negative values due to a decrease in population (even though the decrease in population would equal the long-run rates as already stated).

A suitable question is why shouldn't the long-run rates be positive given that we have inflation in the short run. The answer is that if population will continue to fall then the above-mentioned inflation, driven by property and equity, cannot persist for much longer. As the number of people on the planet is reduces, demand for property is also reduced and more land is available, forcing prices to fall. If this is the case, and no government intervention occurs, then the (very) long-term trend of inflation will be negative. Even at that, the short-term rates will be higher than the long-term ones. As inflation reaches approximately zero, short-term rates will reflect just that, with expectations of inflation being that the trend will stabilize. At that time, long-term rates will continue to be negative and follow the trend of population growth.

What is most likely is this environment is that markets will basically break as nobody would wish to invest in an asset which is losing its value. With working population shrinking, the only remedy I can currently think of is an increase in the retirement age, just like it is being done in most Western countries. Yet, even this has important considerations in the long-run: our bodies are not designed to work until their late 70's (unless we are talking about non-intensive work in which again productivity is reduced) and we cannot view this increase in retirement as a panacea. If abundance through automation is not achieved times might just get more difficult, with inequality rising to new heights.

Friday, 25 October 2013

Population Growth and Interest Rates

One of the most basic tenets of economic modelling (Samuelson and Solow for example) has been that in a stationary economy the interest rate is defined by the rate of growth of the population. If population is decreasing the we get negative interest rates and if population is increasing we get positive ones. I have to admit that I had not given much thought about that until recently since I just considered it to be just another of the great simplifications economists make when they want their models to work. Yet, after reading Samuelson's original model, it somehow got into my head. If one also remembers Krugman's points on Japan and the relationship population has with inflation then the relationship between population, the economy and the interest rate is not as vague as it appears.

It is more often true than not that interest rates reflect inflation. If inflation is high (low), interest rates are also high (low). Yet inflation is not only governed by population; money supply, both commercial bank-created and central bank-created, matters much more in establishing the price level the short-run as do corporate profit margins, import prices and other (for more details see this). If this holds, which it does, it would mean that the shorter the duration of an instrument the larger the effect of the current price level on it. With respect to interest rates, it would mean that the short-run interest rate (e.g. on Treasuries) is more prone to changes in the price level than the long-run rate (e.g. on 20-year Bonds).* This can also be seen in inverted yield curves in times of high inflation.

Continuing with our rationale, it appears that long-term rates are affected by much more things than short-term ones. For example, a fall in the rate of population growth will probably not be visible for the next 5 or so years; new regulations or expected long-term projects and future inflation rates can also be included in this category. However, this should not be confused with long-term equilibria of any kind: this is not something which will work in the long-term if nothing changes (e.g. that GDP will rise in the long-run even if it has been falling in the short-run). This is the idea that results of some action are not visible now either because the change is very little every year or because it takes time for the whole plan to be completed. Think of it this way: we will find out if there is oil in area X but until all the studies and drillings are made 5 or so years will have to pass.

Thus, we can admit that there variables which take much longer to manifest are not having any effect in short-term interest rates but have an effect in long term ones. In the graph which follows, the correlation between bond yields and population growth can be observed. The further right you move along a line the longer the bond duration. 
The correlation, although not being an exact science, points out something very interesting. It appears that irrespective of whether the correlation is positive or negative, the longer the horizon of a bond, the higher the correlation (in absolute numbers). Although correlation does not mean causation, seeing that long-term demographic trends tend to have great effects on interest rates in quite important. The reverse may also hold but in a much broader sense: it does not just take low interest rates to affect population growth, yet an economy in a bad state may have some effect on that. This is not a generalized result however; if it was the all underdeveloped countries would face diminishing populations and all prospering ones would have huge population growth rates. Real life begs to differ with theory here.

Yet the main result is that population matters when it comes to interest rates. For example, have a look in Japan's data since the early 1960's (population growth is reflected on the right-hand axis):

Although changes in the population growth rate are rather small and interest rates are high, it can be clearly seen that the trend is quite similar. As population growth declines the yields in 7- and 10-year bonds follow the same trend. For example, the spike in the population growth rate in the early 1970's was followed by a spike in interest rates in the mid- to late-1970's. Obviously, the spike could also be attributed to other variables changing thus I will not insist too much on it. Still, the long-term trend is more revealing than anything else.

The spikes in yields over the time-frame seen above are not contradictory to what is being described in this post. They are actually more supportive than anything, since there is a magnitude of variables which affect long-term interest rates. As these variables have different effects on the rates it makes more sense for yields to fluctuate over time, depending on which effect is stronger. Nonetheless, interest rates and the economy in general have a strong tendency to prefer growing populations over falling ones for the obvious reason of increased demand. Thus, as correlations and trends indicate, population growth does make a difference in the long-term yields, even if its effects are almost zero in the short-term.

*Those of the readers who are thinking about the annuity formula which shows that if we increase the market interest rate longer annuity have greater fluctuations than shorter term ones I would like to remind that the formula assumes that the same market rate will prevail in all future cases. Yet, if for example, we consider the interest to rise for two years and the return to some lower level, the change in the 20-year bond will be far less than the change in the 1-year or 2-year bond since it will affect just 10% of the former's payments and none at all the present value of the maturity price while it will affect all payments in the latter's case including the maturity value.

Wednesday, 14 August 2013

We Can Have Growth But No Stability

One of the questions I have been asked lately was quite simple and yet it appeared rather hard to answer: "Why do we need growth every year? Why are economists so obsessed with growth and not with stabilizing output to approximately the same amount every year?" The question is usually asked by people who do not view capitalism as a good economic system but are too unwilling to make a change. As a former professor of mine once stated, the best thing in the world is to be a contrarian in a capitalist country; you get to keep both your money and your ideology.*

To be fair, economists do focus on growth. They do it because what they have studied has promoted them to think like that and they consider it so obvious that they waste no time in thinking on why it matters. In fact, we all somehow assume growth is good, we are just unsure why. The simple explanation is that growth is good since it creates more demand, more goods and most importantly more jobs and more money. This is a purely economical (and simplistic) explanation and one which will undoubtedly come under some criticism on the grounds of what people should really focus on or what they should do in their lives (which is really beyond the scope of this article). Still, as far as economics are concerned, growth is assumed to improve the well-being of every individual. 

Ideally, the best outcome of the combined action of policy and markets is full and stable employment. Yet, unless in the cases of war or re-building what the war has destroyed, we have never experienced full employment, and I doubt whether we could ever do that again (unless in wartime). The problem is that if we try to stabilize the system at a level far lower than full employment we would be having more unemployed than we could ideally have and this would create frictions in the markets. Stability would be meaningless if we have too much unemployment; simple logic states that we could do better by improving something. Nevertheless, even a stability scheme would not be sustainable even at full employment for the following reasons:

1. Changing population
Imagine that we have a country with a population of X million people of which Y are in the labour force (obviously Y<X). The unemployment rate is currently 0. During this time, aggregate demand is stable on average. Now imagine that the population rises every year. Unlike conventional economic models, real people do not start working as soon as they are born; they usually cannot do that until they reach a certain age. Thus, the family has to provide for their expenses, which means that although population has risen over time, aggregate demand is still the same as the family still gets the same income (inflation might cause income or demand to rise but this is not a real rise). Thus, assuming that the person will enter the labour force when he or she turns 18, as soon as that age is reached the person enters unemployment. The reason is practically simple: as long as you have stable demand you have no reason to increase your costs by hiring an extra person.

Now, let's assume that it's not just 1 person who enters unemployment each year but Z and they are in fact more than those who retire if we have a positive rate of population growth. Then, by the time firms realize that they have to employ more people to get more income, the number of unemployed increases. Given that such decisions about demand do not really come up so easily (and in addition, every other firm has to act the same way if they want to get back the amount they spend) and people are occasionally picky about what type of job they would like to do (the essence of search and matching theories) growth would be present and unemployment would fluctuate as population rises. 

2. The variable change in demand
In addition to the previous, demand is never stable even in case of full employment. As population changes, be it either growth or decrease, demand is altered every time. This is especially true of specific product demand. When demand is unstable, firms change output to fit it and thus both unemployment and total output fluctuates. Obviously, if the fluctuations are not large then there is no trouble in the system; unemployment may fluctuate but on average it will be stationary. Yet, if fluctuations are so large that the average cannot be maintained then we can forget about the system's stability.

Then question then becomes: why is demand so variable? Is it just because population changes or is there something else hidden behind it? The answer is both: increasing population leads to higher demand and falling population to less demand. Yet, as already stated, increasing population also comes with an increased unemployment rate until the new demand is settled in the economy. Although this may be considered as transitory unemployment, its duration cannot be specified. Decreasing population on the other hand presents the opposite: as demand is lessened, then firms have to scale down their production and thus unemployment is again increased. In both cases, it can be argued that the markets will work in such a way that unemployment rate will be stable in the long run; yet whether this really holds and how long is this long run is debatable.

3. Nature
Do you remember the last time someone predicted a flood? An earthquake? From what we know, nobody has, and it's quite doubtful if anyone will ever be able to do so. In fact, even if we were able to predict them, although human casualties would be minimal, material damages would still be large. We cannot move plants and other infrastructure as fast as we can mobilize people. Hurricane Katrina caused $81 billion of damages in 2005, with Hurricane Sandy causing an additional $68 billion in 2012. If we were in a system in which stability and predictability were the main characteristics then any deviation would wreck panic in the hearts of people. Which brings us to the most important of the factors:

4. Human Psychology
Recent experience indicates that people can either get excited too fast and too much about something (e.g. asset bubbles) or become afraid of something just as fast (market crashes). As the current system (or any system for that matter) functions with people acting within it, it is as stable as its constituent parts. Given that human behaviour ranges from one end of the spectrum to the other, how can we expect a system which is comprised of humans to be stable? More so, people, when acting in large groups fall victims of group psychology of either exuberance or hysteria much faster than when acting alone; in larger systems, the mood swings would be even greater, with larger consequences on them.

To illustrate this, think of person who is not really affected by austerity measures, or who is affected just a little bit. This person may believe that if his income is cut by 10% then he should cut his expenses by 15-20% so that he could save for a rainy day. Now imagine what happens in the economy when 10% of the population decides to do just that (for a tale on what happens this provides an example): demand falls, unemployment rises and a vicious cycle is initiated. This was one of the reasons austerity has not been successful; people fear about the future and tend to react strongly to an event.

Although some could argue that booms may increase demand by just as much crashes reduce it, the truth is that crashes do not really push it down that much. Although human beings are prone to large mood changes (just think of yourself: do you feel the same two days in a row? Doubt it. Most of the times we do not even feel the same in two consecutive hours) we are also prone to optimism and hope. It is against human nature to keep down and do nothing for a substantial period of time and that is how we got to develop from living in caves to exploring space. As Cullen Roche puts it, a measured optimist is the best world view.

Returning to the original question on growth and stability: we cannot stop growth and neither should we try to do so. It's what made us progress through the ages, what brought us the tools we are using now. Stability cannot occur in any economic system as long as it is run by people. Even in traditional economic modelling, population growth equals economic growth. If the system has what it takes to succeed then it will, no matter how many oppose it; if it does not the it will collapse sooner or later. Stability cannot be enforced on a system comprised by people exactly because people are unstable. While many economic models in the literature usually provide for a steady state in their analyses  they never take into account any shocks which could come from within the system, such as agent irrational behaviour or declining population.

The fact is, we need growth for stability as well as for incentives. If we are to grow with a stable rate of, say, 2% per year, then a shock which would contract GDP by 7-8% (note: this shock does not even count as a depression) would mean that we would face high unemployment and deteriorating social standards. Since we cannot eliminate the possibility of a large shock occurring all we can do to safeguard both ourselves and the economy from its impact is have as much growth as we possibly can, before and after the shock. The more growth we have before, the less destructive the shock will be and the less difficult it will be to overcome it and we focus on growth after its occurrence. We do not just aim for stability because stability provides no incentives to create, innovate and develop. For that, we need growth as we also want to be sure that when bad times come (and they will, for sure) we will be less affected by them.

To sum up, stability is something we cannot hope for in a human-based system, at least not in the way we commonly seek it. What we can do to make the most of it, is not criticize growth but try to stabilize that; this will act both as the prevalent force for development as well as a cushion for bad times.

*My personal view on the subject (in case anyone cared) is that although capitalism is the best system we have had until now (or better yet, the only one which survived) it still has plenty of room for improvement. We have gone a long way from the uncontrolled system in the early 1900's where the rich could practically manipulate everything they wanted. Nevertheless, the current system is far from perfect; we should aim for a better future by continuing to improve on our existing structure and not by demolishing it.